In the paper, he observes that during
the last decade higher education in the UK has undergone a profound
transition. Universities, formerly known as public institutions, are
being turned into money
making corporations. This transition of higher education away from a
public good and toward a private good (toward a commodity) is in full
swing and close to completion. Needless to say the effects are
devastating in every respect. However, he argues, it would be a grave error to bemoan this process with sentiments of nostalgia. The public
university, as it is well known, has often been accused of being an
elitist institution. It has been rightly criticised for stabilising and
conserving existing class structures. Is there
a third way? Is it possible to conceptualise higher education beyond
state and market?
Andreas used his presentation as an exercise in utopian thinking. He introduced two developments in higher education that are
situated beyond state and market. The first development
are large scale transnational initiatives such as the 'University of
the People' and the 'Open Education Resource University'. These
initiatives organise education as remote learning and through digital
technologies. They are aimed at students in disadvantaged
areas. While the politics of these initiatives is progressive and
inclusive, the educational philosophy is contestable. It is largely
based on self-education and it outsources some important parts of the
educational process by making a distinction between
the free access of open educational resources on the one hand and small
fees that need to be paid for assessments. The second development are
free university initiatives that organise higher education as a common
good, e.g. the Free University of San Francisco
and the Social Science Centre in Lincoln. These initiatives are very
much in line with autonomous thinking and anarchist concepts of
education. While they should be applauded for introducing alternative
models of higher education, they are also problematic
with respect to the notion of free labour. In order to analyse this
problem he introduces a conceptual distinction between a knowledge
commons and an education commons. Andreas also offered some
general considerations on the growth and the sustainability
of free universities.
Andreas Wittel, "Beyond state and market: Higher education as a Commons", For a Public University Workshop, organised by Prof. Andreas Bieler, University of Nottingham, 15 June 2012